Thermacell Repellent Camp Lanterns

We tried the lantern. It seemed to work.

We weren't comfortable with the possible toxicity of the fumes. The info that comes with it says to not breathe the fumes, which made us wonder exactly what was in it.

Also, you're limited to buying the repellent packets only from the manufacturer, as well as the necessary butane cartridges. I've often refilled butane cartridges, but these are near impossible. More $$$ and more landfill waste.

Yeah well, "probably" isn't a real reassuring way to deal with inhaling unidentified bug repelling vapors. I'd feel better if they'd tell me what exactly it is they don't think I should inhale. Then I could decide for myself! 

Me? I just refrain from showers... Keeps them skeeters a good distance!

I have used both and they both performed reasonably well.  I purchased the portable model on Amazon prime and took it along on my recent trip to Alaska.  Let me provide my experience with the portable unit and a qualifier as well.  

First of all there is no unit that will keep all mosquitoes away in a very wet or humid area where wetlands are nearby or there is a heavily forested area that experienced an abundance of rain and moisture over a season.  I found this out in Michigan's upper peninsula on my way out to Alaska in late July.  The Thermacell unit performed admirably until the sun began to set.  It was at this time that mosquitoes began migrating into the campground, sucked up my Thermacell unit and literally pitched it into the underbrush alongside our camp site.  NOTHING could touch these hungry carnivores and my buddy Tom and I made an amazingly quick retreat back into the comfort and safety of our Little Guy trailers for the night!  There was no beating this pack of mosquitoes and the campground host warned us early on to expect an invasion that would make our stay less than desirable.  Talk about an infestation and major disappointment!

But on the flip side the Alaskan mosquito fear implanted in us was way off the mark.  Mosquitoes up in Alaska this year was a non-issue and after buying up additional mosquito repellent on-line and a head covering, none of it was warranted or necessary.  Yes, I did apply some mosquito lotion to my ankles at times but this was more for the no-seeums as the Thermacell performed well and provided a blanket type coverage within 15' of my trailer.  The Thermacell unit does work under normal conditions, but will be challenged in areas where a heavy mosquito hatch has occurred.  There is nothing known to man short of a major forest fire that can stop a heavy force of invading mosuitoes!  We used our Thermacell units along the trail and all of us were happy with the performance of these units.  I like my Thermacell and do use it frequently when I am enjoying time outdoors and as needed to keep these pesky critters at bay.

Hopefully this will help you out Jim as it is money well spent when taking into account the criteria listed above.  

Mike, thanks for the info on the extreme mosquito pack! I'm glad I wasn't there!

I agree, PXLated. Lemon Eucolyptus Oil (sold under different manufactuerers) is a great thing for the flies and no see ums. I spray it on my ankles and behind my knees and I'm good to go. I found it in Walmart's camping section around the Thermocells